There are ancient battles
in these pages, dusty controversies,
mendicants versus clergy, disputes
long forgotten. But for Henri of Ghent,
Richard Knapwell, Gerard of Abbeville,
the great Aquinas, Bonaventure—they were as
contested as our culture wars today,
though couched in Sententie that march
in noble Latin through these penned notes,
a later scholar dutifully comparing
what seven centuries past was hot debate.
What wisdom can I learn from his staid
calligraphy, black-inked from broad nib,
strolling gracefully on each page?
Here Bonaventure asks, “Are irrational
creatures to be loved ex caritate?
and how Assisi’s Saint
was seen to be a man
of “great fervor and tenderness”
toward them:
“swallows obey
and are silent”
at his sermons—
what any preacher
might hope for.
8 thoughts on "There are ancient battles "
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
nice work here again..
technical Q.. are the pages written on animal skin/parchment? or plantbased fiber/pulp?
i always heard they eventually even used ratskins for writing,
but don’t know if that was true. (?)
dustin, since I am working with a modern scholar who’s commenting on the ancient texts, and who often used microfilms, I can’t say for sure…any of those seem possible.
And ratskins would make a good poem, or a character’s name!!
The last line sends the poem out well in the world. I like you that use link the culture wars of today to the noble Latins.
Thanks, Linda!
I like how the scholars debate, while the swallows listen
I love how you construct your argument early in this poem. It really opens up to me at “Here Bonaventure asks, “Are irrational/creatures to be loved ex caritate?”
I especially like your ending!
great question and image:
What wisdom can I learn from his staid
calligraphy, black-inked from broad nib,
strolling gracefully on each page?