For The Woman Who Delivered Subway Sermons on the Southbound D Train
From 2002- 2008, my morning commute was like clockwork, but no matter where I stood on the platform, even when I dared enter a different subway car than that which would arrive in front of my “usual” spot, a woman managed to enter the same subway car. As soon as the doors shut, she shouted and passionately read Bible passages to us from Fordham Rd. to West 4th Street. Approximately 45 minutes straight, only stopping for air or the occasional sip of water. Sometimes, I wonder where she is. I wonder where she went when she exited the turnstile at the West 4th Street station. This one’s for her, wherever she is.
“stand clear of the closing doors, please.”
**bee boo**
thud.
her black coat glittered with gold verse
as she rolled her wrist and slid her sleeve
to open a well-worn brown book with gold gilt edging
and
to recite what she’s read time and time again.
lady, we all heard you found Jesus, but
I’d like to know where you were
where He was
when He showed up
or
how you found Him, exactly—
was it by accident?
did He bump into you on Sixth Avenue?
did He burst through the bathroom door
in an old tenement building
without knocking, urgently tugging at His fly?
did you close your eyes and whisper a prayer?
did you reveal stigmata wounds
in the arms of a man resembling Pilate–
turn your head at the sight of blood?
did you savor the slipping chance of tasting salvation?
I don’t think I found Jesus.
I’m not sure I was ever supposed to look for Him.
I’m not a good Catholic.
God didn’t bless me with faith,
if that’s how it even works.
what little faith I may have had
must be bouncing along
the slight wobble of the earth’s endless rotation.
I may have left it in a coat closet I cleaned earlier this week
but I can’t be sure.
I don’t know that I ever found Jesus.
was He ever missing?
I don’t see flyers with His face bending around the curves on
the rusty
staple-adorned
telephone poles lining Queens Boulevard.
I’ve passed the same poster for a missing cockapoo for about a year.
I’m tempted to call the number at the bottom of the
weathered poster to see if they found him,
but I never do.
I thought I saw him on the train once-–
Jesus.
He was wearing Ray-Bans and Birkenstocks.
I’m pretty sure he transferred to the L to Williamsburg;
I took the E to Forest Hills.
I thought
I saw him in the eyes
of the women selling fruit
on the Major Deegan
(northbound)
but I was too busy humming along to a soft rock tune that I’d rather not name
because, I am too chicken shit to admit I like it.
I thought I saw Him in the line of tail lights snaking around the bend
at the foot of the George Washington Bridge,
but it couldn’t be
because I forgot the words to “This Little Light of Mine”–
I whistled it instead,
so if people pulled up next to me and heard the melody
I could tell myself I’m a better person than I really am.
you see, I’m not sure if Jesus needs finding;
He may actually be avoiding us,
dodging this idea of a second coming,
because attending once is all you really need to do
to be remembered for trying to save others…
right?
after all the sacrifices are made,
people continue to
request.
plead.
beg.
cry.
hope.
wish.
demand–
of Jesus
for what is
or is not happening
to them
for them
around them
even when they say it’s for someone else,
it never is,
really(.)
according to a Jesuit scholar whose scholarship specializes in Assyriology,
“humans are incapable of true Agape…”
he explains:
“…even in wanting for others, there is a speck of wish that hope is fulfilled, the very nature of that desire to want, even for another, misses the mark of pure selflessness of which only God is capable…”
even if it’s only by a microscopic step along an invisible Planck.
damn.
that’s harsh for an 8 am lecture.
thankfully,
we. can. try. again.
tomorrow.
maybe the rapture isn’t on its way;
maybe it’s already here
and we’re all waiting for it like fools stuck behind
“the train traffic ahead of us”
perhaps,
“we’ll be moving shortly”
too bad we’re stuck sitting
on the B train that never arrives on-time,
while others wax and wane in phases of faith
along the sweltering platform at Fordham Road,
and we’re all too late
because
Jesus already took the bus to Coney Island to catch the sunset,
to wave to the kids at Luna Park
who watch from the rides & dare him to walk on water.
They chant,
“Do it! —
Do it! —
Do it!”–
I hope He disappears without uttering a single word to anyone,
even if he only leaves for a 3-day getaway.
an underpaid security guard will find His hoodie at the top of the Rock,
the makeshift, modern-day shroud claiming He’s somebody’s ‘homeboy’—
a tacky fad from a sportive pre-9/11 past.
upon His return
from the lost and found box
where some still confess (weekly)
others will bear false witness
and tell the children it’s a miracle.
22 thoughts on "For The Woman Who Delivered Subway Sermons on the Southbound D Train"
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
What an amazing, amazing poem. I love the message of it, so many wonderful turns and lines — “what little faith I may have had / must be bouncing along/ the slight wobble of the earth’s endless rotation” is just inspired. Great work!
Thanks, Bill. The chaos unfolding all around us at this moment in time just sparked a memory of her. I wondered what happened to that woman! Thanks for reading. I really appreciate it.
” Just a stranger on the bus,
Tryina make his way home.”
This is a broadside.
Staggering work.
Ah, Joan Osborne. I can hear the opening chords to that song. Thanks for reading, Coleman. It’s much appreciated!
This poem is so fun and clever and speaks to my spirit too. I love the thought of “I’m not sure if Jesus needs finding; He may actually be avoiding us,” I really like this one a great deal. Thanks for sharing.
Thanks so much, Dana! I wasn’t sure if the poem would make sense– especially when the passengers realize they’re on the B train (the long, local route) instead of their beloved D train. Ugh, I’ve made that mistake more than once, and it’s brutal! I’m glad you like this one. Really, thank you!
The cadence here fits with form so well. It’s giving me the power of Jim Wayne Miller’s Briar Sermon.
Wow! Thanks, Shaun. That’s a tremendous compliment. I appreciate that you (and others) took the time to read this one. It’s a little lengthy, but it wasn’t done until it told me it was finished.
…it’s likely still not finished. I’d like to work with this one a bit more. Iron out a few details for clarity and such.
good for you to listen and stay until “it told me it was finished.”
I visited Jim, and heard the same words Jim told our common friend, Loyal Jones when he said: “I prayed out loud just like my dear old Methodist aunt would have, when friends from home came to visit…” Jim’s voice could read a ballad without missing a note, in his rendition…”
Wow!!
I was riveted to all the turns in your imagined response to the woman on the train. Your poem made me remember the panoramic shots of people on St. Peter’s Square waiting for the conclave’s announcement: I’ve never seen so many faces that to me expressed hope
Thank you, Gaby! Yes, the faces in those crowds were hopeful, indeed. I appreciate your close and generous read. 💜
And here I was picturing Jesus in Oakley’s and Adidas. what a goose.
😆 That image works, too. Why not? Thanks for reading!
Sounds like a poem percolating here, inge!
Ooooh! I love it!
wow…wow…wow…
Love how all your poems sing. This one thunders!
I am a regular subway rider as well. You capture the essence of the explosion of complex humanity that exists at platform and on train.
Love the title.
The paragraph of where this poem comes from is a poem in itself.
lol: “stand clear of the closing doors, please.” Truly the hum of a beginning journey
love how music tunes interlace your work: but I was too busy humming along to a soft rock tune that I’d rather not name
PLEASE TELL US!
Fav line: Jesus already took the bus to Coney Island to catch the sunset
Thanks so much, Pam. I am so happy that you hear the rhythm of this one. Maybe I can reveal the song in a different poem? Possibly an idea for a new write for this month. I appreciate your kind words; I guess “If you see something, say something” applies. 😆
Thanks so much for reading.
So much its happening in this poem (helps to understand the lines of the NY subway system ;-). I look at the font selection. to reflect emphasis, how most of the lines are complete thoughts — little enjambment, the imagery (Jesus on his way to Coney Island), the rhythm, assonance and alliteration, and spacing. It’s the kind of poem you must read over and over again to fully appreciate.
Thanks, Lee. I appreciate that you took the time and care to read this. I have thought about this woman every now and again for years. She was very much part of my daily life. Then I moved, took a different subway line, and never saw (or heard) her again. New York, while massive, has its own microcosms that make it feel, in some ways, like a small, intimate place. Thank you again for the read and for the thoughtful comment.